The recent news about the
indiscriminate shooting of cinema goers at a batman movie preview is really
heart breaking and nerve wrecking. The shooter is a young, intelligent and
generally reticent man by the name of James Holmes.
How can a quiet and smart
24-year-old doctoral student go on a rampant killing spree and guns down 12 and
hurts 59 in a cinema in ala Joker-vs-Batman fashion? Can't we tell who is sane
and who is not anymore?
In 1975, a psychologist
David Rosenham conducted an experiment to test how the society view insanity.
He asked seven confederates to join him to gain admission into psychiatric
hospitals. Their admission pass: Tell the hospital staff that they hear voices.
They all got in without any hassle. But the real test is to get out.
While getting in was a
piece of cake, getting out was hell. They spent almost three weeks trying to
convince the staff and doctors that they are sane. The irony is not lost on me:
it is easier to fake mad than to act sane.
But in James Holmes' case,
it's just the opposite. He acted "sane" so well that no one even
suspected he was not. Or is it a case where there was some definitive triggering
point that caused him to go insane. That is, he was basically sane until pushed off the cliff.
Or, at some point, bubbling
beneath his psychological makeup, is a defective gene that has found some form
of expression of violence when the perfect storm of culture, upbringing and
socialization converges under the right condition? Like a oil bunker set alight
by a match. Or like a forest fire ignited by the right channeling wind,
humility and leaf dryness.
I know this is a whole lot
of balderdash and no expert can detect such violent tendencies no matter what
test or early detection is used.
In fact, it is said that a
mad man has lost everything except his reasons. You see, it is not his reason
faculty that is fractured but his perception of reality. And he is basically
acting out in a "reasonable manner" in response to a distorted
reality. It is therefore his reality that is screwed up and not his actions. To
him, he is acting perfectly reasonable. Scary ah?
So, insanity is such a
fungible concept and looking for it is like looking for a needle in a haystack.
For example, in Singapore, for a brief period in November 1967, a scarce broke
out where men thought that their penises were shrinking and withdrawing into
their abdomen. (I can't say at times that I am immune from such thought...mmm).
Some went crazy. They
visited the doctors. Took medication. Rested. And some even drank boy's urine
and ate placenta as a myth cure. You see, distorted reality and reasonable
actions in response.
They say great leaders are
"mad" in some ways. Gandhi and Martin Luther King attempted suicide
when they were teenagers. They were deemed to be suffering from depression. But
it is also said that you find the most realistic and empathic people to be
suffering from some kind of depression. Go figure...
Then, we have JFK and Bill
Clinton, who have issues with their "lower tissues". In fact, it is a
historical fact that JFK is hyper-sexual who had sex with prostitutes and
models. They are basically suffering from (or thriving under) the classic manic
disorder. And yes, most successful leaders have some form of mania or
hyperthymic personality, which make them more resilient and creative. So should
one pray for some madness in your kid? Go figure...
All leaders, admired or
despised (like Hitler and Mao), have one or two screws loose. So, next time you
go into the ballot box, check for some personality disorder as one of the
criteria for your vote.
Now the question is: how do you tell them
apart, the sound and the unsound? Well, the truth is, you can't; for now at least. In the interim, you have to do some
damage control. Be realistic and take precaution. Or, to err on the side of safety.
Therefore, I think the gun culture in America may be the catalyst or gateway to mass killing. They say, "Giving politicians power and money is like giving a teenager alcohol and car keys."
Therefore, I think the gun culture in America may be the catalyst or gateway to mass killing. They say, "Giving politicians power and money is like giving a teenager alcohol and car keys."
Similarly, if you give a
potential border-line, psychopath or schizoid the option of a knife or a gun,
which would result in most harm? The question answers itself. Giving a mad man
a gun is like giving Hitler a nuclear trigger switch promising world
destruction just before he set his claustrophobic bunker aflame.
That's why things like that
(gun-killing) doesn't happen in Singapore, or rarely. I thank God that common
sense, as a foreign migrant, doesn't encounter any problem becoming a permanent
citizen in Singapore, metaphorically speaking.
Let me end unconventionally
with this joke:
"Welcome to the
Psychiatric Hotline:
--if you are
obsessive-compulsive, press 1 repeatedly;
--if you are schizophrenic,
listen closely and a little voice will tell you which number to press;
--if you have borderline
personality disorder, hang up. You have already pushed everybody's
buttons" Cheers out.
(Ps: in case you wondering,
what mental condition do I suffer from? Well, amongst many such as OCD and
narcissism, for starter, I think it's called "Hypergraphia" - the
incurable disease of writing or medically termed as "temporal lobe
epilepsy". Wow, thank God I am as normal as normal is).
No comments:
Post a Comment