I have a
proposition. Let's get rid of religion once and for all. Maybe religion is like
a clutch which the recovered has no use of anymore. Maybe religion is like an
imaginary friend and we adults have grown out of. Maybe religion is like a
ladder and once we have used it to reach high ground, we kick it off.
This
world is experiencing a great convergence and with it comes the crystallization
of secular values. Once we lived
separate and apart, now we are together in the
foxhole of globalization; the flat,
cramped, and standing-room-only world. We are a global local village and we
can fend for ourselves now. We write our own rules with technology our Savior
and science our Cross. The writings are on the wall: We are the masters of our own fate.
Once we
thought rain and drought were the result of unpropitiated deities. Now we know
better. So, it is with religion.
We have reached a new zeitgeist of the times.
We are now more than able to self-govern. We can moralize our lives and set
boundaries for ourselves without looking for a transcendent being at the end of
the religious rainbow.
A world
without religion means that man will no longer depend on an imaginary friend
for comfort, hope and moral guidance. A world without religion means that
prayers are like wasted tossed pennies in an abandoned wishing well. A
world
without religion means that there is no heavenly hope or hellish scares
to keep us hanging in existential uncertainty round the mortal clock.
So, let's
seriously consider this proposition. Let's get rid of all religion. Let's evict
god from his heavenly abode. Let's root him out of our lives so that we may
live without looking over our shoulder for big brother’s approval. Let us tell
god to recreate the genesis of another universe and leave us all alone.
Let us
build an altar of humanity and worship only human effort and human
achievements.
Better still, let’s wake up from our bubbled dream world and
return to the real world where god is clearly a creation of man to ward off the
fear of death and random misfortune. If it is a sense of control we desire, we can very well achieve it without altar sacrifices, tithes and offerings, prayers and fast, and pilgrimages and worship. Wealth-creation, scientific explanations and principles based on humanism are easily more logical and sound substitutes.
Mm...naturally,
with this proposition comes a reservation.
Then, what's next? Having
achieved a good measure of this proposition, what's next? If religion is taken out of the human
equation, what will our future be? Will
the equation be: Man minus god equals peace? Or man plus godlessness equals
betterment?
Honestly,
a world without religion may be a slippery-slope proposition. It's a gambit
that stakes too much on the table. And I fear that when we lose, we may lose
big. Our history has shown us to be self-seeking. It is our evolutionary fate.
And being self seeking, we will do anything to make sure our interest comes
first. The question is, will we be less
self seeking once we get religion out of the way?
If the levee of religion breaks,
what
is going to hold us back from our most basic instinct? Will human laws be the answer? Have we reached a point of evolution where
we can rely on altruistic behavior of reciprocity to overcome our savage past?
In other words, can humans govern
humans in the absence of religion? If the world is going to be ruled by a trustee of atheists,
enlightened and highly celebrated, proscribing and enforcing man-made laws, how
can we be sure that this same group of worldly sages would not act in their
own
interest at the expense of others? Will
the top 0.1 percent come to the unconditional aid of the other 99.9 percent, if
such aid threatens their livelihood, their reputation and their wealth?
Now,
quite naturally, the question is, does
religion then make a difference? Does religion rein in our corruptible nature,
control and channel it for good? Shouldn’t a theist who lives in a glass house
think twice before casting stones at an atheist?
Because we all know that
in that exalted name, many atrocities were committed. In that same name, many
were deluded, deceived and finally de-converted. Even the most religious among
us cannot deny that evil was very much a part of religion as was good.
But I
think herein lies the difference. And let me spell it out by first putting
myself in the atheist's shoes. Let me take away the most presumptuous context
of religion, that is, faith. I
know
that without faith it is impossible to please God. But to an atheist, pleasing
a figment of his imagination is no more self-deluded than thinking that the
earth is still flat. So, let's suspend the argument that God exists. (note that
I am merely suspending the debate about it and not taking it out altogether)
Leaving
aside the debate about the existence of God, what good is religion? How is it more superior than humanism or atheism?
If I can name just one, it would be
this: religion
dethrones us. It sets us in our place. It reins in our most basic instinct,
that is, self. A man who knows no boundaries is a man who can do anything. The
boundaries of religion therefore keeps a man from believing in his own
invincibility. Somehow, the belief that we are not alone, that there is a
higher order of things (the Platonic ideal Forms), that the universe(s) has an
origin and this origin has a specific design, and the design is the product of
creative thought and indissoluble mystery, that we are where and what we are
because of a purposeful convergence of elemental forces that is beyond us and
beyond what our science can ever comprehend, collectively keeps us from readily
taking the fate of humanity into our own hands and screwing it all up in an
accidental pushing of a button marked “nuclear
annihilation” (or something along those fatalistic/nihilistic lines).
What's
more, history has shown that religion is very much a part of us and has molded
our behavior and institutions. I cannot imagine the world today without the cradling hands
of religion and the distilled moral values it impart to the world. For this
reason, I choose to believe that it has done more to redeem us than to condemn
us. It's not a zero-sum game. Neither is it a negative one.
Man can no doubt
govern man.
That's not the issue. The issue is, can man govern himself? To those who answers that question too
quickly, there's a risk that he will be disillusioned just as quickly. He can
moralize all he wants about ethics and the good life, but his morality cannot
save him if he cannot save himself from himself. A woman activist once said
that it is not about power over men but over ourselves that matters most.
If power corrupts, then absolute power corrupts absolutely. For
every Gandhi in this world, I can think of a dozen more Idi Amin to take
his place with inhumane relish. This is the price man pays in a world without
religion. It is no doubt a prize of total freedom. But it is also the price of
total corruption. And this raw and hidden reality in a world without religion
scares the gentle spirit out of me. Cheerz.
No comments:
Post a Comment